Notes from the Design Table
First of all, this is coming together way faster than I expected. I didn’t think this would be ready till next summer. We might be done much sooner.
Losses Not So Bad
This battle is giving me a much different view of casualties. When a unit is destroyed, that doesn’t mean 100% casualties were suffered. In real world terms, it means that 50% casualties were suffered which renders the unit 100% ineffective. Some of those casualties are lost stragglers. Some have minor wounds. They will return to the ranks overnight. At first, I thought I had suffered catastrophic losses on day 2. There is no way I can continue this battle. Maybe this combat is too bloody. I resolved the whole battle in 1 day!
Wait a second. Put half of those guys back on the board and flip everybody up to fresh again. Oh. Ok. That’s not so bad. That looks about historical. We can fight from here.
Lesson learned: All those guys in the dead pile? They aren’t really dead. Half of them spring back to life for the next day. You’re probably ok.
Nice to Have Options
I love the scope of our new map. Most maps here cut off at both historical flanks. Ours is open. It allows you to explore all possibilities. Turn their flank on the left or right. You can try. Realistically, you probably won’t do it. I like ‘not doing’ it because I chose to, NOT because some game rule or map MADE me do that. Big difference.
What is also cool about this, is also the possibility of a Confederate side slip to the right. We are designing this with the possibility of a Pipe Creek defense later as an expansion. Don’t want to defend in Gettysburg? Fine. Fall back to Pipe Creek. First day is a total disaster? You lost Cemetery and Culp’s Hills? Fine. Fall back to Pipe Creek. Confederates were able to side slip to the right and skip out south to Taneytown? Now you better skedaddle down to Pipe Creek!
Interior Lines of Communication
At Antietam, Lee only has 2 Corps. They are somewhat mixed and Lee can be in range of both of them. Confederate HQs are rated higher than the Feds. On top of that, Lee almost always can weigh in with a second opinion when it comes to jumping ahead of a move. 🙂
At Gettysburg, a much different story. So far we are using all HQs rated the same. Still, it’s a huge difference. Mead is on the inside of his fish hook. He is in range of almost all his Corps. He also has many Corps to respond with.
Lee only has 3 Corps. Along the longer stretching lines of communication, which Corps is he able to influence? Usually the wrong one.
So Pender launched an attack on Cemetery Hill. They got lucky and forced the Federals back. In Pub Battles, that doesn’t mean you’ve taken the Hill! It means you have shoved them back and now have a ‘chance’ to take the hill.
The next turn is a race to see who can get back up on Cemetery Hill first! The Confederates have 1 roll to jump ahead and get there: The Corps Commander. Is Lee in range? Probably not.
How many Federal Corps can get there? Almost all of them in one way or another. So there is about 4-6 rolls. Can Mead roll also? Yes. He is in range of just about everybody. Easy. Who is going to get back up there first? Most often the Potomac. Why? Because of interior lines.
Keep in mind that these are very rough and crude play test maps. NOT the final version.